Menu of PRIME at City Market in Dallas, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

PRIME at City Market in Dallas, PA, stands out as a compelling destination for diners who crave quality with a hint of elegance. Located at 2161 Memorial Hwy, this restaurant serves a diverse menu packed with both classic comfort foods and refined dishes. Their reputation is built on an all-day menu focused on elevated sandwiches, enticing flatbreads, and fresh, thoughtfully crafted salads, all prepared with care. The menu’s highlights include the Classic Eggs Benedict and the Black and Bleu Burger, showcasing their mastery of traditional brunch fare and decadent burgers.

From the savory side, the Classic Eggs Benedict is a must-try—not just for breakfast but as an emblem of their kitchen’s consistency and finesse. The delicate hollandaise sauce and perfectly poached eggs blend seamlessly over tender English muffins, a dish that diners like Chuck Y have praised for its flawless execution. Pair this with a well-crafted Bloody Mary or the uniquely refreshing Ruby Red Mule for a balanced and satisfying brunch experience.

Sandwich lovers will find the variety here impressive. The Lobster Roll, though premium at $39, promises fresh seafood flavors balanced by light seasoning and buttery bread. The Beast Burger and BMB Burger appeal to those who enjoy bold, meaty profiles—Anglers like Angela P. appreciated the multi-meat grind and the use of a gluten-free bun, highlighting the restaurant’s attention to dietary preferences without sacrificing flavor.

The flatbreads deserve special mention for their versatility and taste. The Shrimp and Hot Pepper Flatbread and Bamboo Buffalo Chicken Flatbread demonstrate the kitchen’s capacity to carry strong, vibrant flavors without heavy-handedness. These dishes pair well with their cocktails, such as the lively Cranberry Kiss Martini or the summery Strawberry Basil Mojito, both praised by Matt Ide for complementing the rich menu.

Salads here are not mere side dishes but crafted with equal care. The Roasted Beet Salad and the Avocado Salad balance freshness with substance, making them ideal for those seeking lighter, nutrient-packed options. Gail Malloy’s endorsement of the Roasted Beet Salad as a generous and delicious addition underlines the thoughtfulness behind ingredient sourcing and presentation.

Desserts tell their own story. The iconic Peanut Butter Pie and the Lemon Cake anchor the sweet offerings with textures and flavors that are both nostalgic and innovative. However, not all dishes hit the mark flawlessly—as noted by Eileen H, the 'Elvis' crepe didn’t fully deliver on the menu’s promise, missing key ingredients, which hints at occasional inconsistencies in execution.

The service at PRIME at City Market seems generally warm and attentive. Guests describe well-informed waitstaff who guide through the menu thoughtfully, adding to the experience especially during the bustling brunch hours. The atmosphere brings a casual yet refined vibe, boosted by occasional open-air setups that may impact comfort depending on the season.

In summary, PRIME at City Market offers a rich, flavorful menu embedded in a welcoming environment that caters well to locals looking for something beyond the usual chain fare. Its strength lies in the thoughtful balance between classic brunch staples and innovative dishes, supported by commendable service and a solid drink program. While pricing leans toward the higher side, the quality and variety make it a worthwhile stop for both special occasions and regular outings.